Thanks! This did the trick - SELECT CategoryId, MAX( CASE seq WHEN 1 THEN ProductName ELSE '' END ) + ', ' + MAX( CASE seq WHEN 2 THEN ProductName ELSE '' END ) + ', ' + MAX( CASE seq WHEN 3 THEN ProductName ELSE '' END ) + ', ' + MAX( CASE seq WHEN 4 THEN ProductName ELSE '' END ) FROM ( SELECT p1.CategoryId, p1.ProductName, ( SELECT COUNT(*) FROM Northwind.dbo.Products p2 WHERE p2.CategoryId = p1.CategoryId AND p2.ProductName <= p1.ProductName ) FROM Northwind.dbo.Products p1 ) D ( CategoryId, ProductName, seq ) GROUP BY CategoryId ;